Innovation Management and Critical Success Factors in the Brazilian Insurance Market: A Comprehensive Empirical Framework, Sectoral Diagnostic, And Strategic Execution |
| ( Vol-13,Issue-10,October 2026 ) OPEN ACCESS |
| Author(s): |
Marcelo Filipe Rodrigues Urbano, Alexandre Acácio de Andrade, Júlio Francisco Blumetti Facó, Gustavo Rodrigues Ribeiro da Silva |
| Keywords: |
|
Innovation Management; Insurance Market; Critical Success Factors; Organizational Maturity; Strategic Execution Gap |
| Abstract: |
|
Innovation has transitioned from a tactical option to a fundamental strategic imperative for continuous corporate survival, sustainability, and competitive differentiation in the global financial services industry. However, contemporary academic literature lacks a comprehensive, empirical diagnostic framework tailored specifically to emerging markets such as the Brazilian insurance sector. This domain is uniquely characterized by strict state-level oversight under the Superintendence of Private Insurance (SUSEP) and National Council of Private Insurance (CNSP), high economic concentration among major banking and insurance conglomerates, and a historically low market penetration index relative to Gross Domestic Product (GDP). The primary objective of this study is to formulate, structure, and exploratorily assess a multi-dimensional conceptual framework for mapping, measuring, and evaluating critical success factors (CSFs) and organizational practices for innovation in insurance companies operating within Brazil. The methodology comprised a rigorous, systematic literature review spanning international and national academic databases, which grounded the identification, qualitative synthesis, and consolidation of 34 critical practices organized into six thematic dimensions: (1) Innovation Governance, (2) Organizational Culture, (3) Innovation Management, (4) Risks and Compliance, (5) Enabling Technologies, and (6) Human Resources and Innovation Structures. Based on this framework, a dual 5-point Likert scale diagnostic tool was engineered to capture executive perceptions regarding Strategic Relevance (Very Low to Very High) alongside actual operational Adoption Level (Not Used to Plenary). The instrument was exploratorily assess through a field pilot study engaging executive leaders across four representative insurance companies displaying distinct structural and market profiles. The empirical findings confirmed the universal applicability of the framework (85.3% of items rated as 100% applicable) while revealing a critical strategic execution gap: whereas cloud computing, digital platforms, and Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) demonstrate advanced to plenary adoption, foundational managerial dimensions—specifically Innovation Governance, Structured Ideation Processes, Change Management, and Risk Culture—exhibit incipient or intermediate maturity despite being rated with unanimous high strategic relevance by C-level executives. The study contributes a examined in a pilot organizational diagnostic artifact capable of measuring the gap between declared strategy and practical execution, providing executive guidance for resource allocation and laying a rigorous foundation for future large-scale academic research. |
|
|
| Paper Statistics: |
|
| Cite this Article: |
| Click here to get all Styles of Citation using DOI of the article. |



Advanced Engineering Research and Science